Visit our "store" tab for the best in Bloody Angola Podcast merch!
Nov. 17, 2026

Part Two | 50 Shades of Evil: Arizona “The Baseline Killer”

Part Two | 50 Shades of Evil: Arizona “The Baseline Killer”
Part Two | 50 Shades of Evil: Arizona “The Baseline Killer”
Bloody Angola: The Complete Story of America's Bloodiest Prison
Part Two | 50 Shades of Evil: Arizona “The Baseline Killer”
Part 2 of a 2 Part Series
In 2005 and 2006, a predator known as the Baseline Killer turned Phoenix into a city of fear. Over roughly ten months, Mark Goudeau carried out a brutal spree of sexual assaults, armed robberies, kidnappings, and nine murders—mostly of women—many of them near Baseline Road. This episode traces the investigation that linked the attacks, the disguises and methods he used to evade capture, and the DNA and ballistics evidence that ultimately put him on Arizona’s death row with nine death sentences.

Timestamps:
01:38 DNA Evidence Breaks the Case
03:54 Arrest 6:48 From Indictment to Conviction
10:00 Goudeau Addresses the Court
16:50 Death Sentences and New Evidence
19:13 Wendy Carr’s Case for Innocence
29:58 Eyewitnesses, DNA, and Alleged Misconduct
34:34 Final Verdict

Join Bloody Angola on Patreon for Commercial Free Early Releases and more here: www.patreon.com/bloodyangolapodcast

For Louisiana Local Advertising inquiries or to book appearances please email BloodyAngola@gmail.com

0:15 I walk a straight line, shackled and chained. Old Goose and Gertie is calling my name. There is no mercy in this penitentiary. Just ask the hill string gang, a wrangle of three. To die. Inside these walls Inside the wild And when the wolf cries I know it's over.

1:04 Oh, bloody Angola. Oh, bloody Angola. Hey everyone, welcome back to the second and final episode of the Fifty Shades of Evil series on Mark Goudeau, the Arizona serial killer known as the Baseline Killer, who the last time that I left you had killed nine people, sexually assaulted many more, and was still not identified. Now, remember I told you in part one that this case really got slowed down by a false confession, and so at this point in the case, police are really ramping things up, trying to catch some sort of break, and in August of 2006, that break would come. Now before I get into that particular break in the case, I want to tell you about YSTR testing. Now what it does in a nutshell is it builds a DNA profile.

2:25 It focuses only on male DNA and it doesn't need much, just a very small sample size in which to find a match. But the key there is a match. Obviously you have to have a suspect's DNA already on file, which in this case, as it relates to Mark Godot, they did have his DNA on file. You may wonder why? Well, in 2004, when he was released on parole for that 21-year sentence I told you about in episode one, as a condition of that parole, he had to allow a swab of his DNA. Now, as far as how he ended up on the suspect list for these murders and sex assaults, there are really two stories out there that I found in my research. One says his parole officer tipped off police, and another says a woman he had assaulted years prior went to police when she saw that police sketch that I told you about that was released today.

3:33 on billboards, and everywhere else. Regardless, he was on the suspect list, and when police ran the YSTR testing from the DNA of the two sisters that I told you about in Episode 1 who were assaulted in those bushes, a match came back to none other than Mark Godot. So, let's go to September 6th of 2006, which is also incidentally Mark Godot's birthday. So Mark has obviously no idea this DNA has been matched to him. He's driving home from work to the house that he shared with his wife, Wendy, in central Phoenix, Arizona. He pulls down his street and police pull him over. And neighbors would later say that it looked like a routine traffic stop. They take him into custody right there. And inside the vehicle, they also found 3.4 grams of crack cocaine. Now, inside the house, within a few hours, police execute the first of several search warrants. Now, initially, they were looking for shoes described by earlier victims. They pull a pair of white Nikes from that house, and they also find a black ski mask and a clothes hamper. Now, those two items, y'all, when tested, prove damning for Mark Godot. The shoes tested

5:04 positive for Mr. Chew's blood. Remember in episode one, the guy who brought the young lady, it was her first day at work. He was bringing her home. And when they were approaching the car, Mark Godot forced himself into that car and eventually died. would throw Chew out of the car after shooting him in the back of the head. Well, his blood was found on those shoes. And the ski mask that they found at Mark Godot's house also tested positive for Kristen Gibbons' blood. Now, y'all, that is DNA from two murder victims. They also found some blood that tested positive for Sophia Nunez. Another murder victim, if you'll remember, that was one of the ladies in the food truck from episode one. And they also found some DNA from several sexual assault victims who were not murdered. Then a month later, while serving a third search warrant, they find Tina Washington's missing ring that was in a small bag tucked inside a shoe at his house. So, y'all, during all of this, his wife, Wendy Carr, she is telling everyone that will listen that Mark is completely innocent, despite all this evidence that I just told you about. She even had a blog about it, as well as a website called, get this, quote, MarkGudoIsInnocent.com. Now, I did go

6:40 back to that website and check it. It is no longer up. But at the time that all this was going down, that was where she would publish this blog. Now, I am getting ahead of myself a little bit. So let's go back to January 16th of 2007, because that is when Mark is indicted for on 74 felonies. See, originally, he was arrested only for the sex assaults of those two sisters, because that's what they had the damning DNA on at his house, on their shoes. They felt like they had the best case there. But as they worked it, they found DNA for several other victims, like I just told you about. And now they're throwing everything at him.

7:24 The nine homicides, numerous sexual assaults, as well as 12 armed robbery charges. But before the big trial, there's a smaller one. And that matters because it proves the DNA. That smaller trial will actually be based predominantly on DNA. So in September of 2007, the sisters trial takes place and Godot is charged with 19 offenses in that trial. including kidnapping, sex assault, sex abuse, and aggravated assault against those sisters. Plus, that cocaine count for that search of his car upon his arrest. And that jury would convict him on all 19 counts. Every single one of them.

8:15 And he is sentenced on December 14th of 2007. to 438 years in prison. 438 years. And y'all, that's before the big trial. It hadn't even started yet. That trial would start on April 19th of 2011, and it would run over seven and a half months. And I found it interesting that the judge did something kind of unusual with this trial in that he allowed the prosecution to present the evidence in 13 chronological chapters. one for each offense date in order, basically the same way I tell it to y'all when I podcast these episodes. So I actually like the call made by the judge there. Now, seven victims Godot sexually assaulted also testified at that trial.

9:10 One testified that he saw Godot point his weapon downward at a victim's body, and another victim testified that they recognized Godot's voice as the person who sexually assaulted them. But the really undeniable evidence was the DNA found at his home. So after seven and a half months and seven days of deliberation, that jury returns guilty verdicts in 67 counts, including all nine counts of murder. Now, this is on October 31st, which is, you know, Halloween of all days. How's that for poetic justice? And it's in 2011.

9:54 So Godot, he just sat silent, shaking his head as that verdict was announced. and then the trial moves into what's known as the penalty phase of that trial. And this is where Mark Godot does something that really shocks everyone. In the middle of a psychologist testifying on his behalf, Godot cuts it off, stops the whole trial. He waives any more witnesses testifying on his behalf, which is his right, and he addresses the court. And here is what that sounded like. Hi. How are you doing?

10:34 I only get a chance to meet the law. I'm a chief. As the judge, let me introduce myself to you guys. We didn't know exactly who's been watching for the last five months. Mark, there was no wolf in sheep clothing. You would have gotten to know me by my deeds. If my counsel would have presented the defense for me.

11:31 The only reason I'm standing here in front. Of you today. Is because of my past. I'm not proud of my past. Yesterday you heard the word choice quite a few times. We do have choices. I made a choice in 1990. But then I corrected that choice. I was the president.

12:13 Changed my entire life. People can't change. I changed. I became a man. I got married. I got the right support group around me. Because I knew what it took in life. Got out of prison, I never looked back. Never accused nobody, never blamed anybody. I got a job. I went to work every day. I know we're here today because you guys have time to be guilty on the guilty page.

13:17 But I just wanted to introduce myself. I want you guys to know who I am. We cannot do anything. I'm simply here to tell you, my good old, there's no wolf in sheep clothing. I've heard that so many times, I don't know what to say. I have chosen the council mitigation. Yes, I'm in my right mind. The stipulations you heard, I agreed to them.

14:10 And the only. Thing I'm going to add about that is I knew both of those people, both of the victims. Went to school with one. Another one was a longtime friend. Do I regret it? Yes, I do. As you all know, we can't talk about crimes that I had, what you guys have found me guilty of. But I could. look at each and every one of you in your eyes today and tell you Mark Godot is no wolf in sheep clothing. And not to blame any one of you for the decisions you have come to or made. But I do pray that one day that you guys learned the truth about this case or the case that I've been accused of.

15:22 Ladies and gentlemen, Mark Goodall, there's no wolf in sheep's clothing. I mean, I've heard that so many times. They've done that. They've assassinated my character. They painted me to be this monster.

16:04 I'm no monster. And I simply ask the judge for permission to let you know that. Mark Goodall is no monster. I am no monster. I just. Ask whatever is in your heart, I ask you to please. Make it your choice. Thank you. So even faced with all he was facing, y'all, he took no responsibility. He said, you heard it. I'm no wolf in sheep's clothing. And to that, I say bullshit.

16:51 So in the end, Mark Godot, he's sentenced to nine death sentences for all nine murders, plus an additional 1,324 years for these other charges. So including that small trial, plus this big trial, his prison time comes to 1,700 years in prison. plus the nine murders. It's got to be, in all these cases that I've covered, the longest prison sentence I've ever seen. Now, because the death penalty was imposed, this case automatically goes to the Arizona Supreme Court, and that's really kind of to check the T's and dot the I's and make sure that no mistakes were made.

17:40 And in June of 2016... those sentences to death were upheld. Now, during this time, his wife, Wendy Carr, she continues to claim her husband's innocence. And then in the March of 2017, another surprise pops up when the Arizona police announced that DNA testing had linked Godot to yet another sexual assault nearly 20 years later. after that assault occurred. So, this guy clearly, in my opinion, 100% did everything he was convicted of, horrific murders and sexual assaults. It's my belief this guy would have never stopped. Now, upon his conviction, Mark was sent to what's known as Arizona State Prison at Iman. And this is a prison, y'all. It's in Florence, Arizona.

18:33 It's a men's only prison that was opened in 1991. And it houses over 4,500 of the worst inmates in Arizona inside of eight housing units. And that is where Mark Godot is today while he is still awaiting execution. And it's interesting that he still, to this day, maintains his innocence. Now, as far as his wife, Wendy Carr, she maintains a private life now. She's somewhere in Arizona, but she is nowhere near as public as she used to be. No blogs exist anymore. But I went back and I researched if I could come up with any of the blogs that she had written. And I did find one. And I'm going to read that to you because it's interesting. It's kind of her side of what she's saying. Now, I'm going to tell you flat out, I think this guy did everything he was convicted of.

19:34 I have no doubt about it. But I was really curious why this woman would stand beside a guy. I don't care if it's her husband or not. The things that he was accused of and eventually convicted of and that I see there is, you know, a ton of evidence in that direction. There's no denying it, really. I wanted to see where her mind was. So she wrote a petition letter, and I'm going to read that to you. Someone had reproduced it from Wendy Carr's blog, and it says, Subject, justice for Mark Godot and the victims of the unknown baseline killer. This letter is to appeal to your sense of justice for a man wrongly accused and convicted of a crime he did not commit. I beseech you. To take this matter seriously and under consideration, to right a wrong that has been done, I, along with family, friends, and supporters, will tirelessly fight for Mark Godot until justice is restored. Please take a moment to read Mark's story.

20:38 Since the baseline crime started in August of 2005, Phoenix officials relentlessly attempted to find the culprit. They did their job, right? under enormous local and national pressure to solve the Phoenix Baseline and other serial crimes. And after already bungling arrests, James Mullen, Danny Waller, and others, the police were desperate to charge someone and were willing to do anything to secure a conviction. And what she's referencing there, remember in episode one, I told you about a guy who admitted to the crimes and then recanted and police did discover he had nothing to do with it. And they had another suspect at another point in time that they had arrested, but also realized that this guy did not have anything to do with it. So that's what she's referencing there.

21:30 Goes on to say in September of 2006, Mark Godot was arrested in connection with an offense supposedly linked to the baseline crimes. Since Mark's arrest, the police and prosecutors have resorted to unscrupulous behavior to obtain a conviction. For example, at the trial where Mark was convicted of sexually assaulting Lorena and Alejandra Lara, Neither woman had previously ever identified Mark as their attacker, and that's the two sisters. By law, if there is no out-of-court identification, then there can be no in-court identification of the defendant. However, the judge improperly allowed the in-court identification without meeting the requirement for a proper out-of-court identification. This, even after Lorena Lara picked out Mark's attorney, Carrie Lackey, as the suspect at a June 2006 hearing. The Layers were both offered $ 1, 100 a month for one year or longer. Under this bought testimony, their memories are miraculously restored, and they both claim they now recognize Mark as their attacker. More than a year after the assault, and after telling police prior, they can no longer remember the face of the attacker. In another example of the prosecution's tactics, the state consumed the entire DNA evidence, denying the defense the opportunity of independent examination. To compound the injustice, the prosecution's scientist, Lorraine Heath, used methods and

23:03 calculations which are not accepted in the scientific community and were never before allowed in Arizona courts. When defense counsel attempted to introduce accepted methods of calculations, Judge Klein prohibited the calculations on the premise that it was confusing. This egregious act alone caused enough to reconsider the conviction. Mark was arrested, tried, and convicted solely on inconclusive DNA. Nothing more. There's absolutely no evidence linking Mark to the assault of the Lehrer sisters or or any of the baseline crimes. The evidence of Mark's innocence is overwhelming, and it is obvious to any impartial observer familiar with the facts of this case that Mark is innocent of the crimes he has been convicted. Yet, public officials continue to manipulate public opinion through the media, keeping Mark in prison with the real criminal roaming the streets free. Justice for the victims, the people of Phoenix, and Mark Godot require the conduct to be used in this trial to be examined and that the process of appeals be approached fairly. It is also imperative that the upcoming trial against Mark be fair.

24:12 That means the evidence introduced conforms to accepted standards and The defense is allowed to present its case regardless of whether the judge feels it will confuse the jury. And the state does not manipulate or coerce its witnesses and taint the evidence. I plead for your consideration and support to help bring truth to the forefront and save the life of an innocent man. Sincerely, Wendy Carr. And then she goes into the evidence and then in parentheses she put, or more appropriately, lack of evidence. the investigation. Police arrest James Mullins, an inmate in Kentucky who created an elaborate scheme to avoid serving time in Kentucky by confessing to one of the crimes. He was arrested and indicted. Police eventually released him. Okay, what's wrong with that? They realized he had nothing to do with it. The guy was running around saying he committed this crime. Of course, they're going to arrest him, hold him, and see if, in fact, there was any evidence pointing that He did this crime.

25:18 They did that and they released him after. Then she says police arrested Danny Walker in 2005 after being identified by one of the victims, Alejandro Lara. Police later excluded him through DNA. Suspiciously, when Danny Walker was released based on DNA findings, there were no DNA findings. Okay, so I'm not sure exactly what she's trying to say there, but I can tell you the inference is that This guy was the killer and they released him because they had some kind of hard-on for Mark Godot. I mean, come on. She goes on to say the above are only two of the numerous erroneous arrests that have already been made in the baseline crimes. Her next point, with not only local but national media on two and possibly three serial killers, Phoenix police and city officials were under enormous pressure to solve the baseline crimes which had been going on for almost one year. Okay, so what? Of course they were under pressure. There's a guy out there killing people. Mark Godot, actually, out there killing people. We'll move on. It says trial to Mark Godot on July 14th, 2006.

26:29 Darlene Fernandez, an unemployed, mentally unstable meth addict, twice convicted felon with prior gripes against Mark, called the police tip line and Darlene became candidate for a hundred thousand dollar reward. And that, I referenced in this episode I told you about in my research, there was someone that supposedly called a tip line. She goes on to say, based on the call from Darlene Fernandez and without a single bit of supporting evidence, the police referred to Mark as the baseline killer and pursued efforts to arrest him that very same day. Mark was put under surveillance beginning that same day of which no suspicious activity is reported. So because that day he wasn't doing anything suspicious. She uses that as, well, he can't be the baseline killer. Goes on to say DNA evidence. The DNA evidence was sent to the city of Phoenix DNA laboratory, where they determined it was too degraded and the cell material too few for analysis, and it was shelved. After the call from Darlene Fernandez, the task force sent the shelved DNA to the Department of Public Safety crime lab. DPS used a much lower threshold to analyze the data, which resulted in false readings, possibly.

27:44 Uh, no, it didn't. The DNA evidence was made up of a three-person mixture, which makes precise identification of loci, the genetic marker of DNA, virtually impossible. From world-renowned Alan Jameson, director of the Forensic Institute in Glasgow, and she quotes him, I suspect most people imagine that all profiles in DNA obtained from blood, semen, and other clear stain, but often there's no visible stain at all in It's really pointless to even go through that. It's a moot point. His DNA was matched. Goes on to say the acceptable procedure to match DNA is similar to a computer search where you enter your search criteria and the database locates the match. DBS was asked to analyze the DNA against Mark. There was never a cold hit on Mark's DNA in the database. Mark's DNA was fished out of the database and inappropriately manipulated to force a match. Now, how the hell would she know that?

28:43 She wouldn't. She's basically throwing shade on the DNA analysis people in this case. Goes on to say, using a lower threshold and notoriously complicated three-person mixture with the manipulation of the CODIS database... DPS determined the DNA evidence belonged to Mark because it did. And she goes on to just on a rant with this DNA, which is the reason she's doing that is because that's really kind of like the nail in the coffin for Mark Goodo, no pun intended. And she is just trying to hammer that as if she is a DNA expert. This lady don't know anything about DNA. Come on. Goes on to say, in court identification of the victim, there were multiple photo lineups, one of which included Mark. Mark was never picked out by either layer assister. The layers have identified four other men from previous photos. Even after Mark's picture had been splashed across TV for months, the Layers did not mention it to anyone, caseworkers, boyfriends, family, friends, police, or even each other that they recognized Mark. In fact, the Layers sisters have previously told police they can no longer remember the face of their attacker. First of all, I would definitely want to inform anyone that that is common. When you go through a traumatic experience, sometimes it is so traumatic, it is a neurological response, if you will, that you

30:16 cannot remember the face of an attacker. It's nothing new. It goes on to say, when Mark's attorney filed the necessary paperwork because no out-of-court identification had been made, the prosecutors went to Laird's home to discuss identifying Mark, said the woman would recognize Mark as their attacker. Judge Andrew Klein, after the hearing from prosecutors, decided to allow the in-court identification. Judges called there. At a June 2007 hearing regarding identification, Lorena Lara was asked if she saw the man who assaulted her in the courtroom. She responded, I think so. She then said it was the third guy at the table and picked out Mark's attorney, a black man with a lighter complexion than Mark. Mark was sitting in the middle of his two attorneys, and incidentally, I don't know if I've said it, Mark is an African-American, so that's why she referenced the black man with the lighter complexion.

31:11 Also learned during the trial is that the layers were both offered substantial amount of money cloaked in the pretense to relocate for safety. One sister declined the offer. The other is now receiving $ 1, 100 a month for a year. Shortly after Mark's arrest, his wife, Wendy Carr, was shot at home while sleeping one night. The state has not offered her money for safety. How about that? And she's sitting here writing this and making that point. The state has not offered her money for safety, an obvious issue. However, surely if she is offered to testify against him, the state would have been there with the checkbook. And then her last couple of points, she goes to state witness prosecutorial misconduct and bias on the bench. Detective Frank Duran testified to the grand jury that Mark's name first came to his attention after he learned it from Lorraine Heath.

32:04 the state's DNA expert, that there was a hit in CODIS. Later at the LARA trial, Duran changed his story and testified that Mark's name was provided to the DNA technician. He also told Corin Townsend, then Mark's attorney, at an interview in April of 2006, that a list with Mark's name was provided to her. There was never a database hit. She gasped. Makes another point, says in a pretrial hearing, Judge Klein ruled the word match could not be used. However, during the trial, he allowed match to be used. by the prosecutors and Heath despite his previous ruling. In our last section of points, political ramifications. Under enormous pressure and national attention and making several bungled arrests, law enforcement need to make an arrest stick. Even the local Phoenix Business Journal, which reports only on the business community, made an exception and printed a story of heat politicians were taking for these unsolved crimes. Mark's arrest was nothing more than an opportunity for local politicians to pound their chest, slap each other on the back, and pontificate on a good job that they had done. This includes the mayor, and she goes to list. Just a ton of people in the community that are elected officials. Another point, Mark could have easily been quietly arrested at the parole office, which he was on his way home from. But because of the needed media attention, law enforcement waited for Mark to pull up in front of his house. and he was arrested

33:35 under enormous public display of armed police. Mark has been vilified in the media and therefore will never be afforded a fair trial. The general public is ignorant as to the corrupted science used and has read over and over again that his DNA is a match because it fucking was, lady. Goes on to say the jury pool has been tainted and because of the one-sidedness and propaganda, the masses believe Mark is the baseline killer because he is. The two jurors who were going to cast votes of not guilty were deliberately and willfully removed by Judge Andrew Klein. There was no random drawing of lots for alternate jurors, and the entire process was televised and streamed on the internet.

34:19 So what? It should be televised and streamed on the internet. It's called transparency, and it's a right to have transparency in your government, especially your court. related government. So I found it important to read those points because I did want to be at least fair enough to show what Wendy Carr was thinking, because when I learned about her, I'm thinking this lady is a total nut job. Look, I don't know if she's a nut job or not. I've never met her, but I can tell you the evidence is overwhelming. In this case, this guy did it. Maybe she's come to that realization now, but that was her point back then. So there you have it. That is going to do it for this week, and I'm going to wrap up this Fifty Shades of Evil series episode on Mark Godot, the baseline killer. Thank you so much for listening to this two-part series. If you don't like the commercials, check... Listen, y'all, you're going to hear a lot of these up until after Christmas because it's that time of year. But if you don't like them, I get it. I have a Patreon, commercial-free early releases at patreon.com slash bloodyangolapodcast. It helps support the show. Couldn't do it without those folks. And I would appreciate your support.

35:39 And you don't have to listen to commercials. It's super cheap. Go check it out, patreon.com slash bloodyangolapodcast. And until next time, For Bloody Angola, I am your host, Jim Chapman. Much love.