Visit our "store" tab for the best in Bloody Angola Podcast merch!
Aug. 18, 2026

50 Shades of Evil: Nebraska - Charles Starkweather

50 Shades of Evil: Nebraska - Charles Starkweather
50 Shades of Evil: Nebraska - Charles Starkweather
Bloody Angola: The Complete Story of America's Bloodiest Prison
50 Shades of Evil: Nebraska - Charles Starkweather

In January 1958, a 19-year-old high school dropout from Lincoln, Nebraska named Charles Starkweather and his 14-year-old girlfriend Caril Ann Fugate went on a murder spree that left eleven people dead across Nebraska and Wyoming.

Starkweather, who idolized James Dean and styled himself as a rebellious outsider, and Fugate, who claimed she was a hostage, left a trail of bodies that included a teenage couple, a wealthy industrialist and his wife, a traveling salesman, and a young couple in Wyoming. The killings were brutal, impulsive, and seemingly without clear motive beyond rage, alienation, and a twisted desire for notoriety.

Timestamps
03:20 Starkweather's Early Years
06:59 Rebel Without Rules
11:22 First Killings Begin
13:20 The Bartlett Murders
16:36 Help Turns Deadly
19:38 Final Chase Ends
26:28 Execution Day

Join Bloody Angola on Patreon for Commercial Free Early Releases and more here: www.patreon.com/bloodyangolapodcast

For Louisiana Local Advertising inquiries or to book appearances please email BloodyAngola@gmail.com

0:05 H a wall street line, shackle change, Oh weesome, gird, it's calling my name. There is no mercy and it's been a tentery juice as the hill Stream game Rango three, I'm. In bed by me or die inside these walls, inside the wild, hadn't went the girl as I'm.

1:37 Hey everyone, welcome back to Bloody Angola. I'm Jim Chapman, and it's been about ten days since I've dropped an episode, probably the longest I've went. I'm usually solid at the seven day turns on dropping episodes, but I have had some hip and lower back problems that just totally threw me behind. I've been having to do a lot of physical therapy things like that for this. So I'm just now able to get back to recording another episode for you, but not too much longer. I'm like ten days out right now. But we're gonna get to Nebraska and I'm gonna tell you another fifty Shades of Evil story. And I want to paint the picture for you, so I want you to imagine January of nineteen fifty eight. You're in Nebraska, and of course this is flat land and it's January, so it's cold outside snow is lying dirty along the ditches, and in a black nineteen forty nine Ford, a nineteen year old garbage collector who has that James Dean style haircut of that day. He's got a thirty two revolver, and beside him is a fourteen year old girl in that car. Now in the trunk is a body, and on the back roads behind him several bodies of what would become one of the most shocking killing sprees in American history. Eight days, eleven dead, and an entire state was held high by two teenagers. So today I'm going to take you on that deep dive into the story of Charles stark Weather. He was a Nebraska killer.

3:09 We're going to talk about his childhood, what shaped him, those teenage years that would harden him as short as they were in that eight day rampage, that made him infamous. So let's get into it and Charles Raymond stark Weather, he entered the world on November twenty fourth of nineteen thirty eight. This is in Lincoln, Nebraska. Now that city, in most of the country really during this time, was still climbing out of the long shadow of the Depression. Lincoln was the quiet state capital, and it was built on government work, the University of Nebraska, and the surrounding farm economy. In neighborhoods like the ones that Charles stark Weather lived in, they were made of modest framed houses, gravel streets in places, and people still trying to hold on to steady paychecks. Guy stark Weather, he worked as a carpenter and a general laborer. And that was Charles's dad in Helen stark Weather. She would keep the household running.

4:10 They had a large family and Charles was one of seven children, and he wasn't the oldest, nor was he the youngest. He was kind of in the middle there. Now, from early on, Charles would stand out for all the wrong reasons. He was born with bowed legs and that affected his walk, and he also had a noticeable speech impediment. His eyesight was poor enough to require glasses, and he was short and stocky. And I bring this up because these physical traits made Charles go about his young life with kind of a chip on his shoulder. He would start responding to criticism with a quick temper, and he would throw hands all at the drop of a hat, even when he was a child. Now, teachers would later say that he was not what you would call academically strong.

4:59 Sim put, he hated school, and when he felt slighted or embarrassed or bullied, he would disrupt. And there are accounts from this period of his life of deliberate cruelty toward animals, which would speak to the mean street that he was developing really early on. Now, the Starkweather household itself really offered no explanation for this. Large families and working class Lincoln in the nineteen forties and nineteen fifties, they often operated under pressure, Arguments happened, patients would run short, and Charles would later claim his father was harsh and his mother was overwhelmed. But this was the way it was in almost every household during this period of time.

5:45 You're right out of the depression, you're suffering, I mean, you're saving your money, you're scared of the government, you're scared of banks. So this is nothing new for anyone really during this time, and it certainly would go nowhere to explain his rampage later on in life. Now, guns went into the picture early on, and they would really hold Charles's attention. He loved firearms, even at a very young age, and in Nebraska, firearms were common hunting, common thing there, and for Charles they became more than tools. He liked the power that they represented. He would practice with them, and the interest he had in those firearms that was pretty intense. Now by the end of childhood, he had already developed some core traits of someone whose future was not looking good. He had a short fuse, a long memory for insults, and an early comfort with aggression.

6:44 By the time he reached his teenage years, the boy who had fought on the playground, he had already decided the people around him, all of them were enemies. He was the victim right and it was this attitude that would cause him to grow more dangerous over time. So Charles he eventually drops out of high school. Now high school held little interest for him and even less success. Classroom expectations to him felt like another form of judgment, and he answered them the same way he had answered playground insults withdrawal, resentment, and rejection. Once free of school, he took the kind of work available to a young man with limited skills, garbage collection. The job was dirty, it was physical, and it was low status. And it was also around this time that he began to shape his appearance around the images of a rebellion that were circulating in the mid nineteen fifties. That James Dean look that I told you about, sweat back, tear, heavy stare, leather jacket, and the posture of a young man who believed the world owed him something. He became obsessed with having just the look of a rebel. The post was not original to him, but he would wear it with commitment in his mind. The clothes, the hair, the curled lip.

8:06 They weren't a costume. They were proof that he stood apart from ordinary people who followed rules and accepted their place. And in his teenage years, those weapons, they would still remain his thing. He would handle guns with increased familiarity and comfort and the power they represented pretty straightforward and life where he felt dismissed. A gun just would give him a sense of control and a sense of power, and as you would expect, theft and small acts of deviance they would add up nothing yet rose to the level of the later violence, but the direction was consistent.

8:46 Rules were optional with this guy, Consequences were for other people, and force was his answer to everything, including and especially disrespect. Now, the most significant thing that happened to him during this time was a relationship with a thirteen year old girl named Carol Ann Fugaate. They would meet when stark Weather was eighteen and Carol was thirteen. The age gap was obvious, but it wasn't unheard of during this time in history. I mean, remember Elvis was dating Priscilla Pressley when she was like fourteen. But what began is kind of a tension seeking from an older boy quickly became an intense attachment for Fugate. Stark Weather would fixate on her and he would position himself as her protector. Now, Carol, still a young teenage girl living in a difficult household, she was all about it. The two of them built a world in which they were the only people they believed who truly understood each other, and everyone else was an enemy.

9:49 So she was becoming as bad as he was now. Although aside from their attitude it sounded like the perfect love story of two lost souls, it wasn't. The relationship was not gentle. Stark Weather was possessive and he was controlling. He expected loyalty and would lose his shit every time Carol would show signs of independence. Arguments with Carol's family would become a common thing, and her mother and her stepfather made it clear that they did not like this older boy who was consuming their daughter's time and attention. Stark Weather, of course, would tell her this is just further proof that the world was against them, and as any impressionable young teenager would do, she bought right into his bullshit. They would start talking about running away and living kind of a rebellious life with no rules, and the family conflict at home would continue even inside his own home, and Charles would make up his mind that his own family was against him. And what stands out to me in this period is not a sudden break like this guy just all of a sudden went bad.

11:03 It's a steady decline. And by the final months of nineteen fifty seven, Charles stark Weather, at this time nineteen, with a menial job, he convinced himself the only person who mattered was himself and the fourteen year old girl beside him, and the fuse was short and that match was let So let's go to the night of November thirtieth into December first of nineteen fifty seven and Charles stark Weather. He drives to a gas station on what is done as Cornhusker Highway in Lincoln, Nebraska. He needed money. Robert Colvert a twenty one year old attendant and a recent Navy veteran. He was working the late shift at this gas station. In a little about Robert, he was the youngest of six children, and after high school, he served in the US Navy aboard the aircraft carrier USS Shang Grillaw. He was recently discharged from the Navy and he had returned to Nebraska and in nineteen fifty six he gets married. So Starkweather arrives at this gas station and he robs Robert Culvert at gunpoint. He took some money from the register and he forces Robert into his car with him and they drive him to a remote location near the Lincoln Air Force Base where he shoots this guy in the head. He later claimed the shooting happened because Culvert had been slow or disrespectful during the robbery.

12:34 He would say different things, but the explanation typical right for this guy, Any disrespect in his mind justified murder. So he basically said, oh, he didn't walk fast enough. When we had the gun to his back telling him get in the car, so I killed him. Now sadly, at the time of his death, Robert's wife was pregnant with their only child, a daughter, who was born five months later, and people who knew him described him as friendly, just a guy that always smiled, good person, And for the next several weeks, stark Weather returned to something resembling an ordinary life. He continued seeing Caroline fugate, and the murder of Robert Culvert did not seem to FaZe this guy, and then on January twenty first of nineteen fifty eight, he kills again. That afternoon, stark Weather went to his girlfriend's home in Lincoln, and Carol's mother, Velda Bartlett, and her stepfather, Marying Bartlett, and Carol's two year old half sister, Betty Jean. They were all there. An argument starts over the now nineteen year old and these people's fourteen year old daughter. Stark Weather would later give conflicting accounts of who started the argument. What is not in dispute is the killing. Stark Weather shoots both mom and dad, his own girlfriend's mom and dad, killing them, and then he kills the toddler Betty Jean by hitting her and crushing her skull. He then moved the three bodies to an

14:07 outbuilding behind the house and he hides these bodies. Stark Weather and Carol then remained in the house for several days afterward, hiding out. They would eat food in the kitchen, they would watch TV, and they would turn away relatives and even a neighbor who came by curious because this neighbor hadn't seen the family in days and that was rare and strange. So these two they would tell the people that came by, oh, the family, they're sick with the flu. And the bodies would stay hidden while the two of them lived in that home as if nothing ever happened. Then, on January twenty seventh, they finally left. Now stark Weather would take weapons, he would take Ammo.

14:49 He would also take the family car and the first stop for this young couple that day was the form of August Mayor. And August was a seven your old man, seventy years old, y'all. He lived alone. He had a very well kept farm about two miles east of Bennett, Nebraska, and he had spent his entire life on that farm, never married, and people who knew him described him as soft spoken, very hard working, neat and just a great guy. Neighbors said his farm was better maintained the most state parks in Nebraska. He took pride in his work, and he was also a man of faith. And incidentally, he was also a family friend of the stark Weathers. He had known Charles since Charles was born and even allowed Guy stark Weather and his sons to hunt on his land.

15:43 As a matter of fact, it was that prior relationship that led Charles stark Weather and Carol Anne Fugate to go there after leaving Carroll's parents' house. So the couple went there with the specific intent to rob and kill Mayor. Charles stark Weather knew him, and he knew this was kind of an easy target, older guy. Right when they arrive, stark Weather shoots Mayor in the head with a shotgun, and he also killed Mayor's dog just to be a deck. Mayor's body was then dragged into a warehouse slash outbuilding behind the main house and it gets partially hidden now. Stark Weather and Fugate then took money, food, and guns from that property. They leave and they head down the road, and as soon as they leave, uh oh, they get stuck in the mud and they can't get their car out.

16:37 Robert Jensen and Carol King see this. They see this car stuck in the mud. They see this stranded pair, and they stop to help. And this is a common courtesy on those roads in this part of Nebraska. So Robert Bobby Jensen, he was just seventeen years old, sharp kid, junior class president at Bennett High School. He played football and he was very well liked. And Carol King, she was just sixteen years old. She was a cheerleader at the same school. She sang in the choir. She was a good student. The two of those were high school sweethearts, just in the wrong place at the wrong time, just trying to be nice and help these people stuck in the mud. So as soon as they walk up to stark Weather, stark Weather immediately pulls a gun on them.

17:27 He robs Jensen of a small amount of money, y'all four bucks. He then forces Jensen to drive them a short distance to an abandoned storm seller. Now at that storm seller, stark Weather ordered Jensen down the steps. This kid walks down the steps and Charles stark Weather shoots him six times in the head. Jensen's body falls to the bottom of the stairs and was just left there as far as Carol King, she was shot once in the head and her by body was found partially undressed. Her genes and underwear were actually pulled down around her ankles, and she had been stabbed repeatedly in the abdomen, growing and genital area. And of course stark Weather later on upon his arrest, would give conflicting statements. He would sometimes claim he was the one responsible for both killings, and at other times he would blame Carol for shooting King or for the stabbing aspect as it related to King, saying she acted out in jealousy because he had found King attractive. So they kill these two kids. They leave the bodies in the storm cellar, and they take off now in Jensen's dark blue nineteen fifty Ford. Then on January twenty eighth, the killings moved into what you may say was a higher social bracket than what they've done before.

18:53 The couple started targeting the wealthy. Stark Weather and Carol would enter the home of See Laurel Ward, who was a wealthy Lincoln businessman now Ward, he wasn't there at first. They entered the home and his wife was there, Clara, and their living maid was there, Lilian. As soon as they bust in, stark Weather would control the house. When see Laura Ward returned, he was shot and he was killed. Then Claire Ward and Lilian they were also killed, stabbed and bound in addition to being shot. The three bodies were then left inside the residents and stark Weather took clothes, money in the Wards nineteen fifty six Black Packard. The couple then drove west down the highway, so the final killing occurred near Douglas, Wyoming. This was on January twenty ninth.

19:48 A guy by the name of Merle Collision, who was a trifling shoe salesman. He had pulled his Buick off to the side of the road. He was tired, he wanted to rest. Star Weather sees this approaches, shoots and kills this man right there in broad daylight, and he attempts to steal his car. However, the Buick had this kind of complex push button transmission that stark Weather could not figure out how to operate. And while he struggled with this vehicle, trying to get it to start. A young geologist by the name of Joe Sprinkle he comes up upon this scene and he sees all this. He realizes what's happened in a fight follows between him and stark Weather, and during the fight, a Wyoming Deputy sheriff named Bill Rummer he arrives on the scene. Stark Weather sees the deputy. He takes off running, jumps in the car.

20:48 This deputy follows, gives chase from behind, and the pursuit ends when the stark Weather's vehicle again becomes stuck in the mud. He's then taken into custody along with his young girlfriend. So stark Weather, being who he was, he was not the type to remain silent. He's almost proud about doing this shit, which is not a good idea when you've killed eleven people. In the hours in the days after that arrest, he would talk and talk and talk, admitting to every killing. Now, Wyoming and Nebraska both had victims in this case, with the final murder having occurred in Wyoming, but the bulk of the victims and the stronger set of charges belonged to Nebraska. So stark Weather would return to Lincoln, Nebraska, and prosecutors they made what I consider an interesting choice. Rather than attempt to try him for every murder at once, they concentrated on a single, totally provable case. They charge stark Weather with the murder of Robert Jensen. In the evidence vents was strong. They had ballistics, they have the stolen car, they had Charles stark Weather's own freaking confession, and the sequence of events also matched up to where they could get a conviction.

22:12 So one solid conviction for first degree murder is really all the state needed for the death penalty. So this trial starts in May of nineteen fifty eight. Can you believe that talk about moving fast compared to how fast trials moved today, which is not fast at all. Right, But it starts in May of nineteen fifty eight. It's in Lancaster County, and the courtroom, as you can imagine, is packed with reporters, and stark Weather when he appeared in court still had that same fifties look, the hairstyle, the posture that he had worked on for years. His demeanor would draw as much attention as the testimony and the facts of the Jensen's killings were difficult to hear, but very damning to Charles stark Weather. The prosecution would lay out a straightforward case. Stark Weather had robbed Jensen, forced him into that storm cellar, and shot him repeatedly in the head. Carol's presence and actions were part of the narrative they brought it up, but the charge against stark Weather would stand on its own. The jury did not deliberate long. They found him guilty of first degree murder and the sentence was death in the electric chair at Nebraska State Penitentiary. Now Caroline Fegate. She was tried separately, and she was fifteen by the time of her trial.

23:37 She was still a minor under the law, but the state treated her as an active participant, which she was in all these crimes. The prosecution argued she had aided and abetted, that she had opportunities to escape or ask for help and had never taken them, and that her presence and actions throughout this killing made her feminally responsible. Now her defense, they would say he coerced her, and that she was scared of Charles and that's why she just stayed with him this whole time. And she maintained that stark Weather had threatened her that she believed her family was still alive and in danger. Is she resisted, and that she had been held hostage rather than a partner.

24:23 But the jury they didn't buy that bullshit. They rejected this hostage narrative, and they convict her of first green murder in the perpetration of a robbery in connection with Jensen's death. But because of her age, she received a life sentence rather than death. She would serve only seventeen and a half years before being paroled in nineteen seventy six. Jim, did you see what happened in Texas today? Wait before you tell me that, let me tell you what happened in New York. It cannot be as crazy as the case I told you about yesterday in Louisiana. You know what, we should do a podcast about it, and with that we did. Crime War Weekly covers the crime news headlines that have dominated the week. We cover trending crimes from all over the country and even sprinkle in a few globally.

25:17 Crime War Weekly is available now wherever you listen to your podcasts, simply by searching Crime War Weekly or clicking the link in the description of this podcast. Now of course, the media coverage around this was insane. Newspapers and magazines were in the photographs, and everybody in the entire country at this time was just enthralled with this case. And it was They had news back then, the three channels, but they didn't have Internet during that time, so it was full newspaper glory back then, where the front page of every paper in the country was following this trial.

26:03 And stark Weather himself, he would give interviews, he would write letters while he was in jail, and he would continue to adjust his account of Carroll's role depending on the moment in the audience. None of it altered that legal outcome. And throughout all these appeals where he was saying all those things, none of it stood except the conviction and the death sentence as well. So he gets transferred to Nebraska State Penitentiary and Lincoln to await execution, and on the night of June twenty fourth into June twenty fifth of nineteen fifty nine, the state of Nebraska prepared to carry out that sentence only a year after his conviction. Crazy right to think that hadn't been that damn long ago and now you pretty much die in prison way before you're executed. In most cases it's just wild.

26:58 But for stark Weather, the time was up for him. He ate his last meal, and then he met with the warden and the priest, and when the time came, he was taken to the execution chamber. The switches flip and Charles Starkweather was pronounced dead shortly after midnight on June twenty fifth of nineteen fifty nine. Now, after Carol Ann Fugate was paroled, she left Nebraska. She lived quietly under her married name in another state, and she largely avoided the public eye. Now, the argument over her exact degree of culpability did not end with her release. It continued in books, documentaries, and conversations among people who still studied the case. Some still view her to this day as a course teenager who had survived the only way she knew how, and others held that her actions and her failures to escape or seek help made her a willing participant a lot of opportunities where she could have escaped and chose not to. Now, in the years that have followed, this story became one of the foundational American narratives of the youthful killing spree. The images from nineteen fifty eight, The leather Jacket, the Young Girl, the ordinary Rhods that turned into crime scenes proved something that could stand the test of time. Later on in life, a movie came out and you probably heard of this movie.

28:31 It was starred in by Woody Harrelson and it was called Natural Born Killers. And that movie was inspired by this story, and even Bruce Springsteen titled an entire album Nebraska and opened it with a song written from Inside the Mind of a serial killer modeled on stark Weather. Of course, true crime books, television documentaries and podcasts like this one would feature the k as well now the electric chair at Nebraska State Penitentiary. It may have ended Charles Starkweather's life on a June night in nineteen fifty nine, but the story left behind didn't end with him. It continues to this day as one of, if not the most shocking in the evil cases to ever come out of the state of Nebraska. So there you have it, fifty Shades of Evil Nebraska. I'll be back soon to bring you another one. Check out the Patreon for commercial, free early releases and Morepatreon dot com, slash Bloody Andngola podcast.

29:41 Thank you so much for your support. Say a prayer, if you will, for my lower back and my hip, that I can get some relief from all of this pain every time I sit down to record a podcast. But until next time for Bloody and Gola, I'm your host. Jim Chapman a twelve mm. I walked straight line Shackle Chaine. Oh go someome girdie.

30:26 It's calling my name. There is no mercy and this being a tentery juice as the hill stream game Wrangle three. I'm here but. By mere or die inside these walls, inside the wild. And went noir As I know it's overbody angled, ohbody ang